What if the most dangerous man aboard a pirate ship wasn’t the one threatening you with a sword—but the one offering you a friendly smile?
On July 18, 1938, just one week after terrifying America with Dracula, 23-year-old Orson Welles returned to the microphone with Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island. And this time, he became one of literature’s most irresistible villains: Long John Silver.
Welcome to Episode 2 of Listen with Gilbert, Chesterton Radio’s original companion to the legendary Mercury Theatre on the Air.
Broadcasting from our little independent radio station on Commercial Street in Atchison, Kansas, we’re setting sail with Welles, young Jim Hawkins, and a ship full of characters whose greatest dangers aren’t always what they seem.
But this is more than a pirate adventure.
Why do we find charming villains so irresistible? Can intelligence and courage exist without goodness? And what would G. K. Chesterton’s understanding of wonder, greed, and human nature help us discover about Stevenson’s extraordinary story?
Along the way, we’ll explore Welles’s remarkable performance, the magic of radio drama, and a delicious paradox: the pirates are so obsessed with finding treasure that they nearly miss the adventure itself.
It’s a voyage worth taking. And you don’t need a treasure map.
Listen to the original Mercury Theatre production:
Previously on Listen with Gilbert:
Dracula: The Night Orson Welles Opened the Door
Next voyage: A Tale of Two Cities — Dickens, revolution, and the extraordinary power of sacrifice.
Great Stories Deserve to Be Heard. Help Keep Them Alive.
Listen with Gilbert is an original Chesterton Radio production, made possible by the generosity of our paid subscribers.
For just $8 a month, you can help keep our independent station broadcasting and support original programs that bring great literature, classic radio, wit, wonder, and enduring ideas to new generations.
We’re not a corporate network. We’re a little station in Atchison, Kansas, with a big affection for stories worth telling.
If this is the kind of radio you believe should exist, become a paid subscriber.
Become a paid subscriber at ChestertonRadio.com
Thank you for keeping the door open.
Chesterton Radio — The Open Door.
Great stories. Great ideas. Always welcome.











