Can artificial intelligence make something beautiful—or can it only imitate beauty?
Catholic songwriter Justin West writes the words, then uses AI to create music and images that have reached millions. His argument raises a provocative question: What if AI isn’t replacing an artist? What if the alternative is that the song, painting, or story would never have existed at all?
In this episode of The Common Room, we explore AI and creativity through Peter’s Barque, C.S. Lewis, St. John Paul II, Catholic teaching on artificial intelligence—and Chesterton Radio’s own experiment with AI-assisted storytelling.
A traditional radio drama once required writers, actors, directors, engineers, musicians, artists, and a studio. Today, one person with new tools can attempt to create an entire repertory company.
Something has clearly been gained.
But has something human been lost?
And if a song or story moves you before you know how it was made, does discovering that AI helped create it make it any less beautiful?
Perhaps the most important question isn’t simply “Was this made by AI?”
It may be:
“Where is the human being in this?”
