What if the person you couldn’t stand was the person you were falling in love with?
In Ernst Lubitsch’s delightful 1940 classic The Shop Around the Corner, James Stewart and Margaret Sullavan play two feuding shop employees who unknowingly become anonymous romantic pen pals. It’s funny, surprisingly moving, and one of Hollywood’s most perceptive stories about love, loneliness, and the magic of Christmas.
In this episode of Common Room at the Movies, we explore the legendary Lubitsch touch, the film’s remarkable cast, and its fascinating journey from the silver screen to classic radio—including a 1941 Lux Radio Theatre production starring Claudette Colbert and Don Ameche.
We’ll also discover how this little Budapest shop inspired She Loves Me and You’ve Got Mail, and why its story feels particularly at home along Commercial Street in Atchison, Kansas.
And there’s a local reason to celebrate: The Shop Around the Corner comes to Atchison’s Fox Theatre on Monday, December 14, 2026.
Pull up a chair in the Common Room. There are wonderful stories behind this little shop.
Common Room at the Movies is a Chesterton Radio original, broadcast from the little station on Commercial Street in Atchison, Kansas, and made possible by our paid subscribers. Become a paid subscriber at ChestertonRadio.com and help keep the stories playing.












